you're reading...
Association of Discipline Defense Counsel, David Cameron Carr, Engstrom Lipscomb & Lack, Howard Miller, Howard Rice, Jerome Falk, Ninth Circuit, Paul Triana, State Bar Court, Uncategorized

David Cameron Carr: “It is Good to Be King”

Mr. David Cameron Carr — an expert in the area of legal ethics and the
current President of the California-based Association of Discipline
Defense Counsel — has publicly criticized the State Bar of California, Howard Rice’s Jerome Falk, as well as Thomas Girardi and Howard Miller,
over the handling of disciplinary proceedings concerning misconduct by
Thomas Girardi and Walter Lack in the litigation against Dole Food
Company.

David Cameron Carr
Mr David Cameron Carr, believes that “all lawyers must understand the
rules of legal ethics, not only to fulfill their responsibilities to
society and to the justice system, but to protect themselves.”
(Photo credit: www.123people.com )

In a shocking move, Mr. Carr -– a former California State Bar prosecutor
–- offered a stinging rebuke to Jerome Falk’s decision not to pursue any
discipline against Girardi and Lack despite the clear findings of
misconduct on their part by the Ninth Circuit.

Previously, in a rare action, the Ninth Circuit suspended Walter Lack
and Paul Triana of Engstrom Lipscomb & Lack for 6 months, and
reprimanded Thomas Girardi of Girardi & Keese, while imposing close
to $400,000 in monetary sanctions. Specifically, the Ninth Circuit found that the misconduct by Walter Lack
and Thomas Girardi involved “the persistent use of known falsehoods,”
and that the “false representations” were made “knowingly,
intentionally, and recklessly.”
Carr, writing on his blog http://www.ethics-lawyer.com/kafkaesq/ in an
entry labeled “It is Good to Be King,” wrote as follows on January 21,
2011:

“It’s hard to escape the troubling thought that, had Mr. Girardi
and Mr. Lack been different lawyers with no connection to the State Bar
like Howard Miller, the process and perhaps even the result would have
been much different.”

Mr. Carr offered legal analysis, referring to “Bus. & Prof. Code
section 6068(d) (codifying lawyer’s duty not ‘to seek to mislead the
judge or any judicial officer by an artifice or false statement of fact
or law.’). As a matter of law, this, most assuredly, would warrant the
imposition of discipline in California.” Mr. Carr continued, noting
that “the lack of intent to mislead the court doesn’t seem to matter for
culpability purposes in State Bar Court.”

In his conclusion, Carr stated: “As a discipline defender, I am not inclined to second guess a
decision not to prosecute a discipline case. And I don’t know all the
facts that went into Mr. Falk’s exercise of discretion; he isn’t talking
and neither is the State Bar. But I do know, now as ever, it is good to
be king. Or at least very close to one. Very very good.”

According to confidental sources , Mr. Carr should be commended for his
courage in speaking up, as well as his intellectual honesty and
integrity – the defining traits of a good lawyer. One confidential source believe, however, that some of Mr. Carr’s
comments regarding “intent” are superfluous as Walter Lack had
stipulated that his misconduct was “intentional.” See http://www.law.com/jsp/article.jsp?id=1202434690835

About these ads

About Leslie Brodie

Leslie Brodie is a reporter, writer, blogger, activist, and a religious leader in the community.

Discussion

Comments are closed.

Categories

RSS .

  • Closure of Plumas / Sierra Regional Courthouse 2014/10/24
    Only four years ago, amid great fanfare, the former AOC heralded the opening of the Plumas/Sierra Regional Courthouse in Portola. This 6500-square-foot courthouse, which features a “prominent transparent glazed entry vestibule and tall clerestoried lobby” along with its single courtroom, was built at a cost of $4.7 million.  In the AOC’s words, it “exemplifi […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • Jerry’s pfabulous spending spree…. 2014/10/16
    Jerry Pfab is the phearless leader of the facilities maintenance unit in the Judicial Council. Several months ago we described to you how Jerry is setting public funds ablaze so that he can place a little pick-axe representing the prospectors award on his various printed materials and business cards. The judicial council even recognized him […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • You have until October 20th to register to vote. 2014/10/04
    We would like to join the MyVote Democracy At Work Project and encourage each and every one of you to vote. What’s more is we’re going to make doing so brain-dead easy. Register to vote in person or by mail by clicking here. *(1) Yup, there is no easier way to register to vote than by […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • Alliance Members Identify Priorities for Incoming Administrative Director 2014/10/03
      We asked our membership to suggest priorities for the incoming Administrative Director of the Courts, Martin Hoshino. Thank you to our members who took the time to lay out priorities for the judicial branch. Here we will attempt to summarize those responses, which we plan to share with Mr. Hoshino when we meet with […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • Let’s talk delay, deny and obfuscate…. 2014/09/24
    In just a few days the judicial council staff offices will greet Martin Hoshino as their new executive director. If you have observed what we’ve observed about the judicial council over the last several years then you know that the state auditor was about to issue a report on her audit of the entity formerly […]
    Judicial Council Watcher

RSS Drudge Report Feed

  • RODE SUBWAY HOURS BEFORE TESTING POSITIVE... 2014/10/24
    RODE SUBWAY HOURS BEFORE TESTING POSITIVE...(Top headline, 1st story, link)Related stories:HAD CLEARED ENHANCED AIRPORT SCREENING...Cops Caught Throwing Ebola Waste in Public Trash Cans...HHS: TRUST US...CLAIM: Patients being 'disappeared'...
  • HAD CLEARED ENHANCED AIRPORT SCREENING... 2014/10/24
    HAD CLEARED ENHANCED AIRPORT SCREENING...(Top headline, 2nd story, link)Related stories:RODE SUBWAY HOURS BEFORE TESTING POSITIVE...Cops Caught Throwing Ebola Waste in Public Trash Cans...HHS: TRUST US...CLAIM: Patients being 'disappeared'...
  • Cops Caught Throwing Ebola Waste in Public Trash Cans... 2014/10/24
    Cops Caught Throwing Ebola Waste in Public Trash Cans...(Top headline, 3rd story, link)Related stories:RODE SUBWAY HOURS BEFORE TESTING POSITIVE...HAD CLEARED ENHANCED AIRPORT SCREENING...HHS: TRUST US...CLAIM: Patients being 'disappeared'...
  • HHS: TRUST US... 2014/10/24
    HHS: TRUST US...(Top headline, 4th story, link)Related stories:RODE SUBWAY HOURS BEFORE TESTING POSITIVE...HAD CLEARED ENHANCED AIRPORT SCREENING...Cops Caught Throwing Ebola Waste in Public Trash Cans...CLAIM: Patients being 'disappeared'...
  • CLAIM: Patients being 'disappeared'... 2014/10/24
    CLAIM: Patients being 'disappeared'...(Top headline, 5th story, link)Related stories:RODE SUBWAY HOURS BEFORE TESTING POSITIVE...HAD CLEARED ENHANCED AIRPORT SCREENING...Cops Caught Throwing Ebola Waste in Public Trash Cans...HHS: TRUST US...
  • EBOLA REACHES CONCRETE JUNGLE 2014/10/24
    EBOLA REACHES CONCRETE JUNGLE(Main headline, 1st story, link)
  • PUTIN LASHES OUT AT USA... 2014/10/24
    PUTIN LASHES OUT AT USA...(First column, 1st story, link)
  • QUEEN TWEETS... 2014/10/24
    QUEEN TWEETS...(First column, 2nd story, link)
  • NYT: RECORD LOW WORLD SERIES RATINGS HIGHLIGHTS TREND AWAY FROM BASEBALL... 2014/10/24
    NYT: RECORD LOW WORLD SERIES RATINGS HIGHLIGHTS TREND AWAY FROM BASEBALL...(First column, 3rd story, link)
  • LAZY LIFESTYLE CAN BE AS DEADLY AS SMOKING... 2014/10/24
    LAZY LIFESTYLE CAN BE AS DEADLY AS SMOKING...(First column, 4th story, link)Related stories:SUNLIGHT KEY TO BEATING DIABETES...
  • SUNLIGHT KEY TO BEATING DIABETES... 2014/10/24
    SUNLIGHT KEY TO BEATING DIABETES...(First column, 5th story, link)Related stories:LAZY LIFESTYLE CAN BE AS DEADLY AS SMOKING...
  • BULLY GROUP TO LEWINSKY: TAKE YOUR STAINED DRESS HOME! 2014/10/24
    BULLY GROUP TO LEWINSKY: TAKE YOUR STAINED DRESS HOME!(First column, 6th story, link)Related stories:WSJ: Look for attempts to rewrite '90s history....
  • WSJ: Look for attempts to rewrite '90s history.... 2014/10/24
    WSJ: Look for attempts to rewrite '90s history....(First column, 7th story, link)Related stories:BULLY GROUP TO LEWINSKY: TAKE YOUR STAINED DRESS HOME!
  • BLAME GAME BEGINS... 2014/10/24
    BLAME GAME BEGINS...(First column, 8th story, link)Related stories:DEM IN DANGER: 'The president's not relevant. He's gone in two years'...Black disappointment with Obama threatens party...Race Baiting in MD...Michelle O confuses Colorado Senate Dem with GOP Challenger...DNC Boss Can't Name Single Senate Race O Has Campaigned In... […]
  • DEM IN DANGER: 'The president's not relevant. He's gone in two years'... 2014/10/24
    DEM IN DANGER: 'The president's not relevant. He's gone in two years'...(First column, 9th story, link)Related stories:BLAME GAME BEGINS...Black disappointment with Obama threatens party...Race Baiting in MD...Michelle O confuses Colorado Senate Dem with GOP Challenger...DNC Boss Can't Name Single Senate Race O Has Campaigned In... […]
  • Black disappointment with Obama threatens party... 2014/10/24
    Black disappointment with Obama threatens party...(First column, 10th story, link)Related stories:BLAME GAME BEGINS...DEM IN DANGER: 'The president's not relevant. He's gone in two years'...Race Baiting in MD...Michelle O confuses Colorado Senate Dem with GOP Challenger...DNC Boss Can't Name Single Senate Race O Has Campaigned In... […]
  • Race Baiting in MD... 2014/10/24
    Race Baiting in MD...(First column, 11th story, link)Related stories:BLAME GAME BEGINS...DEM IN DANGER: 'The president's not relevant. He's gone in two years'...Black disappointment with Obama threatens party...Michelle O confuses Colorado Senate Dem with GOP Challenger...DNC Boss Can't Name Single Senate Race O Has Campaigned In... […]
  • Michelle O confuses Colorado Senate Dem with GOP Challenger... 2014/10/24
    Michelle O confuses Colorado Senate Dem with GOP Challenger...(First column, 12th story, link)Related stories:BLAME GAME BEGINS...DEM IN DANGER: 'The president's not relevant. He's gone in two years'...Black disappointment with Obama threatens party...Race Baiting in MD...DNC Boss Can't Name Single Senate Race O Has Campaigned In... […]
  • DNC Boss Can't Name Single Senate Race O Has Campaigned In... 2014/10/24
    DNC Boss Can't Name Single Senate Race O Has Campaigned In...(First column, 13th story, link)Related stories:BLAME GAME BEGINS...DEM IN DANGER: 'The president's not relevant. He's gone in two years'...Black disappointment with Obama threatens party...Race Baiting in MD...Michelle O confuses Colorado Senate Dem with GOP Challenger... […]
  • UBER Tests On-Demand Flu Shots... 2014/10/24
    UBER Tests On-Demand Flu Shots...(First column, 14th story, link)
.
%d bloggers like this: