you're reading...
Association of Discipline Defense Counsel, David Cameron Carr, Engstrom Lipscomb & Lack, Howard Miller, Howard Rice, Jerome Falk, Ninth Circuit, Paul Triana, State Bar Court, Uncategorized

David Cameron Carr: “It is Good to Be King”

Mr. David Cameron Carr — an expert in the area of legal ethics and the
current President of the California-based Association of Discipline
Defense Counsel — has publicly criticized the State Bar of California, Howard Rice’s Jerome Falk, as well as Thomas Girardi and Howard Miller,
over the handling of disciplinary proceedings concerning misconduct by
Thomas Girardi and Walter Lack in the litigation against Dole Food

David Cameron Carr
Mr David Cameron Carr, believes that “all lawyers must understand the
rules of legal ethics, not only to fulfill their responsibilities to
society and to the justice system, but to protect themselves.”
(Photo credit: )

In a shocking move, Mr. Carr -– a former California State Bar prosecutor
–- offered a stinging rebuke to Jerome Falk’s decision not to pursue any
discipline against Girardi and Lack despite the clear findings of
misconduct on their part by the Ninth Circuit.

Previously, in a rare action, the Ninth Circuit suspended Walter Lack
and Paul Triana of Engstrom Lipscomb & Lack for 6 months, and
reprimanded Thomas Girardi of Girardi & Keese, while imposing close
to $400,000 in monetary sanctions. Specifically, the Ninth Circuit found that the misconduct by Walter Lack
and Thomas Girardi involved “the persistent use of known falsehoods,”
and that the “false representations” were made “knowingly,
intentionally, and recklessly.”
Carr, writing on his blog in an
entry labeled “It is Good to Be King,” wrote as follows on January 21,

“It’s hard to escape the troubling thought that, had Mr. Girardi
and Mr. Lack been different lawyers with no connection to the State Bar
like Howard Miller, the process and perhaps even the result would have
been much different.”

Mr. Carr offered legal analysis, referring to “Bus. & Prof. Code
section 6068(d) (codifying lawyer’s duty not ‘to seek to mislead the
judge or any judicial officer by an artifice or false statement of fact
or law.’). As a matter of law, this, most assuredly, would warrant the
imposition of discipline in California.” Mr. Carr continued, noting
that “the lack of intent to mislead the court doesn’t seem to matter for
culpability purposes in State Bar Court.”

In his conclusion, Carr stated: “As a discipline defender, I am not inclined to second guess a
decision not to prosecute a discipline case. And I don’t know all the
facts that went into Mr. Falk’s exercise of discretion; he isn’t talking
and neither is the State Bar. But I do know, now as ever, it is good to
be king. Or at least very close to one. Very very good.”

According to confidental sources , Mr. Carr should be commended for his
courage in speaking up, as well as his intellectual honesty and
integrity – the defining traits of a good lawyer. One confidential source believe, however, that some of Mr. Carr’s
comments regarding “intent” are superfluous as Walter Lack had
stipulated that his misconduct was “intentional.” See

About Leslie Brodie

Leslie Brodie is a reporter, writer, blogger, activist, and a religious leader in the community.


Comments are closed.



  • Unveiling Another Power Grab 2015/11/19
    November 18, 2015 Back in January 2014, amid much fanfare, the Chief Justice announced the formation of a Commission on the Future of California’s Court System.  The Futures Commission’s charge was to develop “practical, achievable recommendations that may be implemented by the Judicial Council, the Legislature, or the Governor.” The Alliance has learned tha […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • AOC will stay put….Ignores SEC and State Auditor 2015/11/09
    San Francisco is a very expensive place in which to do business. Bloomberg Business reports that, in addition to sky-high rents for apartment dwellers and businesses, San Francisco is now the world’s most expensive place for visitors to spend the night. Parking, gasoline, groceries—everything costs more in The City. So why does the AOC insist […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • Vocal Trial Court Advocates Dumped From Key Committee 2015/11/04
    Few of us have the time or the attention span to follow the machinations of the Judicial Council’s various advisory bodies. Judging by the press releases that clutter our email inboxes, many of these committees simply approve staff recommendations and pass out awards. But the latest developments at the Trial Court Budget Advisory Committee (TCBAC)—the […] […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • Say it ain’t so…. Jody’s dog spot is retiring? 2015/10/16
    Update & Corrected: A confirmed message which arrived in our inbox indicates that Curt Soderlund, better known as Jody’s dog spot that has followed her around on a boy leash has announced his retirement. Replacing Curt Child will be a former CDCR exec named Millicent Tidwell. We’re going to miss Curt because he was […] […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • Judge Tia Fisher Retires; Two new directors are appointed to the ACJ 2015/10/14
    Alliance director and Los Angeles Superior Court Judge Tia Fisher has retired from the bench and moved out of state. Judge Fisher played a crucial role in the Alliance’s successful efforts to put an end to CCMS and bring about an audit of the AOC. She was a regular presence in the halls of the […]
    Judicial Council Watcher

RSS Drudge Report Feed

%d bloggers like this: