you're reading...
Alliance of California Judges, David Lampe, Uncategorized

Judge W. Kent Hamlin Letter of Resignation from CJA

Subject: My Letter of Resignation from CJA

Dear Mr. Bissey:

I write to explain to you why I am resigning from the California Judges Association after having been a member for over 12 years, and after having served for most of those 12 years on the Criminal Law and Procedure Committee, both as a member and as chairperson. I have chosen to send this message because you deserve an explanation why judges are leaving the association you have faithfully served for so many years. Notwithstanding my decision and the views I express here in support of it, you should be aware that I have the greatest respect for you and your staff, in particular Legislative Counsel, Jordan Posamentier, and Membership and Administrative Coordinator, Michael Reilly.

When I first became a director of the Alliance of California Judges early last year, I believed that our two associations could complement one another in representing the interests of the state’s judges. I believe the vast majority of Alliance members felt the same way. I now see that is impossible. CJA is largely populated by members interested only in attending occasional meetings and educational conferences, while their leadership acts as apologists for the Judicial Council and the Administrative Office of the Courts.

Having watched this development over the years, I frankly find it rather embarrassing. The leadership of CJA has fallen so completely out of touch with the membership that CJA board members take action on behalf of the association without any apparent concern for the opinions of their constituency. This trend has now become so pronounced that there is little reason to believe the association can ever again represent the views of the state’s judiciary.

While one may trace the beginnings of this trend back to the implementation of state trial court funding, the unchecked growth of the AOC to the detriment of trial court independence, and the virtual abdication of CJA’s role as an independent authority on judicial ethics, recent events have brought this fundamental defect further into focus. The dysfunction of the association is now so glaring it can no longer be ignored.

A few examples will illustrate this point. First, Judge Davis went — perhaps on his own initiative or perhaps at the behest of other branch leaders — to Assembly Majority Leader Charles Calderon, identified himself as the President of CJA, and urged Mr. Calderon not to proceed with AB 1208, the Trial Court Rights Act of 2011. Judge Davis first failed to respond to press inquiries about the visit, then claimed he was speaking on his own behalf and not as CJA President, and then at the CJA Mid-year Conference he blithely stated, “Some of us will take witnesses with us in the future when we meet with legislators.” Does anyone really believe that Judge Davis went to the Assembly Majority Leader to discuss AB 1208 — the most important piece of legislation to affect the governance of the judiciary in years — without identifying himself as CJA President? Is there a reason Judge Davis could not simply admit his error in judgment in advocating against legislation withou t direction from CJA members and the board?

Then there is the matter of the CJA survey on AB 1208. This was truly a disgrace, a view I shared with you in the attached email at the time the survey was released. The CJA board created a subcommittee to draft the survey, that group drafted a neutral survey designed to obtain an honest view of the membership about AB 1208 and various governance issues, and then by an email or telephonic vote of the executive committee of the board, the question that clearly sought agreement with the proposition that “judicial branch governance should remain within the judicial branch itself, and not become a function of external political processes” was added. How can anyone look at that behavior and not be offended by the efforts of these CJA “leaders” to slant the survey to ensure the results of the survey matched their own personal views about governance of the judiciary and AB 1208?

Several of those leaders demonstrated their desire to slant the CJA survey results toward their own personal views even after the survey results were tabulated. The worst example of this conduct was CJA board member Judge James Herman’s attempt to pit the judges of Los Angeles against the rest of the state’s judiciary by sending a letter to the Chief Justice on false CJA letterhead. Regarding that outrageous conduct, these statements were attributed to you last month in a Courthouse News article:

“Judge Herman was out of line sending his own letter to the chief on faux CJA letterhead,” said Bissey. “He used art from our website –not the official CJA logo or masthead, apparently right clicked to save the art and pasted into his own message.” “The positioning of Los Angeles versus the rest of the State (real or not) is not helpful from a CJA perspective and as much as it may seem like an ultimatum, CJA would be radically different should we face the mass exodus of 500 members from Los Angeles for membership in yet another potential rival Judges association,” Bissey noted. He added that one member of the board “going rogue” is not helpful to the association as a whole nor within its rules. “This was unacceptable,” wrote Bissey, “and something needs to be done to show the rest of the board that we cannot have 25 individual spokespeople as the voice of the judiciary.”

I could not agree more. Unfortunately, Judge Davis chose to ignore your sentiments and give Judge Herman an unconditional pardon for his inappropriate behavior. He did all but publicly apologize to Judge Herman for the “misunderstanding” that flowed from his divisive attempt to speak for the association on false letterhead that he created without authorization. In his desperate attempt to “save” his friend from further criticism and “rescue” the Chief Justice from further embarrassment over the actions of the judge she had only recently appointed to chair the Judicial Council committee overseeing CCMS, Judge Davis disrespected you and the membership of the association by again putting his personal goals first.

For years now, those of us who took the bench after the transition to JRS-II have been told that one of the most important goals of CJA has been JRS-II reform; that the goal is to obtain legislative assistance that might permit judges to retire with a defined pension benefit before age 65. Acknowledging that the current state of the economy is not conducive to enhancing retirement benefits, CJA members understand that a fix of this kind will probably have to come as part of a larger bill that affects public employee benefits generally, but none of us expects that CJA has thrown in the towel on this issue. But in an email dated June 8, describing to CJA members in his district his legislative outreach efforts on behalf of CJA, Judge Herman wrote, “The education of the legislators on our pension issues was critically important and our local legislators were appreciative of the information and supportive, recognizing our pensions do not need reform.” While that positio n may make Judge Herman popular with his local legislators, it leaves this CJA member further convinced that CJA’s leaders are out of touch with the concerns of the membership.

Finally, CJA’s committee structure appears unsuited to the task of moving quickly to speak out on important matters affecting the judiciary. Apparently the CJA Ethics Committee was of the view that the “Interim Amendments” to the Rules governing the Commission on Judicial Performance — which would have greatly handicapped judges and exposed them to enhanced discipline in the event they offered new information after the initial statement of intended discipline by the CJP — did not merit opposition by CJA because the amendments implicated “procedural rather than ethical issues.” It would appear that CJA only took a position after its leaders learned of the strong opposition to the amendments expressed by the Alliance of California Judges and several Superior Courts. CJA should lead on an issue of this importance; it cannot be the “Voice of the Judiciary” if it only weighs in after others have forced its hand.

For the first five years I was a judge, I needed the disability coverage provided through CJA, but that need has long since passed. Until I found a much better rate elsewhere and replaced it, I thought I needed CJA for an affordable group rate life insurance policy. My insurance coverage that provides legal representation in matters before the Commission on Judicial Performance comes from the AOC, not CJA. So I sit looking at my CJA dues invoice and I ask myself, “Why should I continue to put my hard-earned money into an association whose leadership acts contrary to the interests of its members and views its primary role as one of providing unfailing support for the AOC and Judicial Council?”

Perhaps CJA can once again represent the interests of the judges of the State of California. Should that happen, I will consider rejoining the association. For that to take place, CJA’s leaders must come to realize that their role is to represent judges, the vast majority of whom serve in the trial courts, even if that requires them to take principled stands against the policies and initiatives of the Administrative Office of the Courts, the Judicial Council and the Chief Justice. The current board has repeatedly demonstrated that your views as Executive Director, and those of the rank and file members of the association, matter very little to them as they choose to promote their own personal agendas at the expense of the association as a whole. They are now free to pursue their own self-interest without my financial assistance.

Sincerely,

W. Kent Hamlin

Superior Court of California for the County of Fresno

Advertisements

About Leslie Brodie

Leslie Brodie is a reporter, writer, blogger, activist, and a religious leader in the community.

Discussion

Comments are closed.

Categories

RSS .

  • Yet Another Unlicensed Contractor Debacle 2017/07/10
    This story is late in publishing because the AOC (ahem, the judicial council) spent months drawing out our requests for information on a simple inquiry they should have been able to deliver on the same day it was received because what scant information they did provide was readily available to them. But they dragged out […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • Another Clifford Ham boondoggle in San Diego 2017/04/19
    More false promises of tunnels reaching out from jails to courthouses. Don’t say we didn’t tell you so because we’ve stated many times that ALL tunnel promises are false promises made to win local support of the projects and penciled out upon approval. What we find most disturbing is that Clifford Ham has a track […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • Writing our obit is a bit premature… 2017/04/06
    Welcome to 2017! Yeah, we know, a bit of time has passed since we’ve been hyperactive here. We’ve been a bit busy frying other fish.  If you consider yourself a progressive, you’ve already read and possibly even recognized our work elsewhere. We will be continuing those projects and check in here as not to neglect […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • Welcome to the first business day of our reinvigorated 10 year run! 2017/01/02
    Thanks to the sheer incompetence of Judicial Council staff leadership, we’re going to be spending the next ten years nipping at their heels. Last week, the San Francisco trial court ruled that the Jacobs entities maintained their contractors license and that the 22.7 million that the Judicial Council should have been able to recover is […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • Working for the Judicial Council and a pattern of racketeering activity 2016/10/31
    The Racketeer Influenced and Corrupt Organizations Act, commonly referred to as the RICO Act or simply RICO, is a United States federal law that provides for extended criminal penalties and a civil cause of action for acts performed as part of an ongoing criminal organization. The RICO Act focuses specifically on racketeering, and it allows […]
    Judicial Council Watcher

RSS Drudge Report Feed

  • GOLDMAN SACHS: IT'S GOING TO BE A GREAT NEW YEAR... 2017/11/19
    GOLDMAN SACHS: IT'S GOING TO BE A GREAT NEW YEAR... (Top headline, 1st story, link) Related stories:Economy to roar in '18...
  • Economy to roar in '18... 2017/11/19
    Economy to roar in '18... (Top headline, 2nd story, link) Related stories:GOLDMAN SACHS: IT'S GOING TO BE A GREAT NEW YEAR...
  • RUSSELL SIMMONS SEX ASSAULT CLAIM 2017/11/19
    RUSSELL SIMMONS SEX ASSAULT CLAIM (Main headline, 1st story, link)
  • Why Firm Believer in Tax Cuts Could Derail Senate Plan... 2017/11/19
    Why Firm Believer in Tax Cuts Could Derail Senate Plan... (First column, 1st story, link)
  • POLL: Trump approval tops Merkel, May, Macron... 2017/11/19
    POLL: Trump approval tops Merkel, May, Macron... (First column, 2nd story, link)
  • 'SNL' Takes Aim at Alum Al Franken... 2017/11/19
    'SNL' Takes Aim at Alum Al Franken... (First column, 3rd story, link) Related stories:LAPD investigates two dozen sex crime cases tied to Hollywood...MORE Ratner Accusations...91 ON HARVEY HITLIST...Dunham Apologizes for Defending 'GIRLS' Producer Against Rape Allegation...Inside celeb 'addict' summer camp... […]
  • LAPD investigates two dozen sex crime cases tied to Hollywood... 2017/11/19
    LAPD investigates two dozen sex crime cases tied to Hollywood... (First column, 4th story, link) Related stories:'SNL' Takes Aim at Alum Al Franken...MORE Ratner Accusations...91 ON HARVEY HITLIST...Dunham Apologizes for Defending 'GIRLS' Producer Against Rape Allegation...Inside celeb 'addict' summer camp... […]
  • MORE Ratner Accusations... 2017/11/19
    MORE Ratner Accusations... (First column, 5th story, link) Related stories:'SNL' Takes Aim at Alum Al Franken...LAPD investigates two dozen sex crime cases tied to Hollywood...91 ON HARVEY HITLIST...Dunham Apologizes for Defending 'GIRLS' Producer Against Rape Allegation...Inside celeb 'addict' summer camp... […]
  • 91 ON HARVEY HITLIST... 2017/11/19
    91 ON HARVEY HITLIST... (First column, 6th story, link) Related stories:'SNL' Takes Aim at Alum Al Franken...LAPD investigates two dozen sex crime cases tied to Hollywood...MORE Ratner Accusations...Dunham Apologizes for Defending 'GIRLS' Producer Against Rape Allegation...Inside celeb 'addict' summer camp... […]
  • Dunham Apologizes for Defending 'GIRLS' Producer Against Rape Allegation... 2017/11/19
    Dunham Apologizes for Defending 'GIRLS' Producer Against Rape Allegation... (First column, 7th story, link) Related stories:'SNL' Takes Aim at Alum Al Franken...LAPD investigates two dozen sex crime cases tied to Hollywood...MORE Ratner Accusations...91 ON HARVEY HITLIST...Inside celeb 'addict' summer camp... […]
  • Inside celeb 'addict' summer camp... 2017/11/19
    Inside celeb 'addict' summer camp... (First column, 8th story, link) Related stories:'SNL' Takes Aim at Alum Al Franken...LAPD investigates two dozen sex crime cases tied to Hollywood...MORE Ratner Accusations...91 ON HARVEY HITLIST...Dunham Apologizes for Defending 'GIRLS' Producer Against Rape Allegation... […]
  • Sexual misconduct claims roil Alabama senate campaign, divide women... 2017/11/19
    Sexual misconduct claims roil Alabama senate campaign, divide women... (First column, 9th story, link) Related stories:Battle with the gays...
  • Battle with the gays... 2017/11/19
    Battle with the gays... (First column, 10th story, link) Related stories:Sexual misconduct claims roil Alabama senate campaign, divide women...
  • 100 full moons: Blazing fireball lights up Arctic sky... 2017/11/19
    100 full moons: Blazing fireball lights up Arctic sky... (First column, 11th story, link)
  • Mugabe dismissed by party, replaced by 'The Crocodile'... 2017/11/19
    Mugabe dismissed by party, replaced by 'The Crocodile'... (Second column, 1st story, link) Related stories:Dictator goes on hunger strike...
  • Dictator goes on hunger strike... 2017/11/19
    Dictator goes on hunger strike... (Second column, 2nd story, link) Related stories:Mugabe dismissed by party, replaced by 'The Crocodile'...
  • Toy Grenade Causes Scare, Evacuation At Miami Airport... 2017/11/19
    Toy Grenade Causes Scare, Evacuation At Miami Airport... (Second column, 3rd story, link)
  • Professor's eerie lethal drone video haunts... 2017/11/19
    Professor's eerie lethal drone video haunts... (Second column, 4th story, link)
  • TRUMP SPARES THE ELEPHANTS... 2017/11/19
    TRUMP SPARES THE ELEPHANTS... (Second column, 5th story, link) Related stories:Faced public and private pressure...
  • Faced public and private pressure... 2017/11/19
    Faced public and private pressure... (Second column, 6th story, link) Related stories:TRUMP SPARES THE ELEPHANTS...
.
%d bloggers like this: