archives

Fogel v. Farmers Group

This category contains 56 posts

Los Angeles Sheriff’s Department Lee Baca and Thomas Girardi — Published 09/01/2011 | Beverly Hills Courier

Sources: Inquiry Launched into Los Angeles Superior Court Judge William Highberger’s Impartiality in Matter of Fogel v Farmers Group

An inquiry has been launched into the impartiality of the judge presiding over the matter of Fogel v. Farmers, The Leslie Brodie Report has learned.

This inquiry was launched following a review of Consumer Dogwatch legal team’s motion to disqualify Judge William Highberger (See http://goo.gl/FGSNB ) , as well as unsubstantiated allegations concerning Judge Highberger, Carolyn Kuhl-Highberger, and Thomas Girardi of Girardi & Keese.

According to sources familiar with the situation, the inquiry will examine the possibility of tacit involvement by Judge Highberger in the circumstances surrounding concurrent representation by the law offices of Girardi & Keese and Skadden Arps.

Specifically, despite their respective roles as counsel for plaintiffs and defendants in Fogel v. Farmers, Girardi & Keese and Skadden Arps entered into a separate agreement by which Skadden Arps and partner Thomas Nolan represented Girardi & Keese and Thomas Girardi before the Ninth Circuit in the matter of In re Girardi following the Ninth Circuit’s issuance of an order to show cause why Girardi & Keese, Engstrom Lipscomb & Lack, Thomas Girardi, and Walter Lack should not be suspended, disbarred, or otherwise sanctioned as a result of the massive fraud which took place in litigation pursued by them against Dole Food Company.

While both cases were pending, and over a period of 4-5 years, neither the Ninth Circuit nor the Los Angeles County Superior Court (nor, for that matter, the class of plaintiffs which Girardi allegedly represents) were ever informed of the concurrent representation.  See http://tinyurl.com/fogelvfarmersobjection

Update 1 – Fogel v Farmers Group, Inc. — Class-Action Settlement

The Leslie Brodie Report (TLR) is carefully following  developments relating to the case of Benjamin Fogel vs. Farmers Group, Inc. currently pending before the Los Angeles Superior Court.  We will provide coverage and post updates as they become available.

— Opposition to Objection by State of Montana Submitted to the Court on August 24, 2011.

— Said opposition presently not part of court documents posted on official settlement website.

— Plans underway for formal motion to intervene and vacate any judgment which doesn’t address, in a meaningful way, issues relating to the concurrent representation.

— List of objectors grows, and now also include: BRILLIANT MARVIN, CASEY MICHAEL, CHOI HYUNG, COLEMAN BOBBIE JOE SR., COPE STEVEN,CORSER JOSEPH, CORSER NANCY, EHMKE JOSHUA,
ELLIOTT JANICE,HEARD MATTIE, JOHNSON MARK, KEMPER ANNE, LEVERETS LUCY, LYONS GEORGE,RUDOLPH LORENA, REYES ESTELLA,RICHARDS ALEX,RUDOLPH JAMES,SCHUH CHARMAIN,VALLEE JAMES ,VARELA MELODY,

LAKE DAVID N. LAW OFFICES OF APC – Attorney for Objector
LAW OFFICES OF EVAN A. NIELSEN – Attorney for Plaintiff/Petitioner
LAW OFFICES OF R. KEITH PERKINS – Attorney for Plaintiff/Petitioner
LOCKE LORD BISSELL & LIDDELL LLP – Attorney for Defendant/Respondent
LONGLEY & MAXWELL LLP – Attorney for Plaintiff/Petitioner
MILLER STEVE A. – Attorney for Objector
OFFERMAN & KING LLP – Objector
PALMER DARRELL LAW OFFICES OF – Attorney for Objector
SHERWOOD ALAN J. – Attorney for Objector
WINN KATHERINE LAW OFFICES OF – Attorney for Objector

08/24/2011 Opposition Document (to mtn-intervene filed by State of Montana and certain Montana class members )
Filed by Attorney for Defendant/Respondent

08/24/2011 Opposition Document (and joinder to Defts’ oppo to mtn to intervene by State of Montana and individual consumers )
Filed by Attorney for Plaintiff/Petitioner

Future Hearings
09/02/2011 at 11:00 am in department 307 at 600 South Commonwealth Ave., Los Angeles, CA 90005
Status Conference (FINAL APPROVAL READINESSCONFERENCE)

09/07/2011 at 09:00 am in department 307 at 600 South Commonwealth Ave., Los Angeles, CA 90005
APPROVAL – SETTLEMENT (1) HEARING RE FINAL APPROVAL OF CLASS ACTION SETTLEMENT2) MOTION FOR ATTORNEY FEES3) MTN-INTERVENE4) PRO HAC VICE)

PointOfLaw Forum: Fogel v. Farmers Group: CCAF challenges $90m fee in claims-made settlement

FORUM

« Around the web, August 22 |

August 23, 2011

Fogel v. Farmers Group: CCAF challenges $90m fee in claims-made settlement

The Fogel v. Farmers Group settlement seems impressive from the notice: $455 million! When you get to the fine print, it turns out that class members have to jump through hoops to claim amounts as small as under a dollar, and that anything not claimed will revert to Farmers affiliates. Even if the settlement was worth $455 million, the $90 million fee request is excessive. The Center for Class Action Fairness LLC has objected on behalf of two class members. More: LA Times; Consumer Watchdog.

Interestingly, class counsel is Thomas Girardi, who POL reported on here; the defense attorneys are Skadden, which represented Girardi in In re Girardi.

Posted by Ted Frank at 9:38 AM
Tags: , , , , ,

Ethics Complaint filed with California State Bar against Skadden Arps’ Thomas Nolan/Raoul Kennedy and Girardi Keese’s Thomas Girardi/Graham LippSmith for Alleged Misconduct in Fogel v. Farmers Group Inc.

<img style=”margin: 0px;” title=”null” src=”http://mooker.com/backend/uploads/1/police-siren-animated.gif&#8221; alt=”null” width=”500″ height=”70″ />

TLR has learned an ethics complaint alleging multiple acts of misconduct has been filed with the State Bar of California against attorneys from the firms of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher & Flom LLP and Girardi & Keese.

Knowledgeable sources, speaking on condition of anonymity, maintain the complaint alleges that ethical breaches took place as a result of Skadden Arps’ representation of Girardi & Keese in the matter of In Re Girardi because, at the same time, Girardi & Keese and Skadden Arps were on opposing sides in the case of Fogel v. Farmers Group, Inc.

According to the sources, the parties named in the complaint are Raoul Kennedy, Thomas Nolan, and Richard Zurmoski of Skadden Arps as well as Graham LippSmith and Thomas Girardi of Girardi & Keese.

<img style=”margin: 0px;” src=”http://t3.gstatic.com/images?q=tbn:ANd9GcQ_h8ZvcHSm4_GhiYpKwD3XbnjNcVMhNJ0PWYekBXcRombYWwZN8xL-Hg&#8221; alt=”” width=”100″ height=”150″ />Thomas Girardi of Girardi & Keese
From left, Messrs. Raoul Kennedy, Thomas Nolan, Thomas Girardi and Graham LippSmith.

The complaint alleges that in August 2003, Walter Lack (of Engstrom, Lipscomb & Lack) and Thomas Girardi and Graham LippSmith (of Girardi & Keese) filed a class action suit on behalf of plaintiffs Benjamin Fogel against Farmers Group, Inc. in Los Angeles County Superior Court.  The suit — which is still pending and is anticipated to settle in September 2011 — was defended by attorneys from Skadden Arps (Raoul Kennedy and Richard Zurmoski).

Despite their respective roles as plaintiffs’ counsel and defendants’ counsel in Fogel v. Farmers, Girardi & Keese and Skadden Arps entered into an agreement by which Skadden Arps and partner Thomas Nolan would represent Girardi & Keese and Thomas Girardi before the Ninth Circuit in the matter of In re Girardi following the Ninth Circuit’s issuance of an order to show cause why Girardi & Keese, Engstrom Lipscomb & Lack, Thomas Girardi, and Walter Lack should not be suspended, disbarred, or otherwise sanctioned as a result of the massive fraud which took place in litigation pursued by them against Dole Food Company.

On July 13, 2010, the Ninth Circuit issued an order suspending Walter Lack for a period of six months and reprimanding Girardi; the order also imposed almost $500,000 in monetary sanctions against the two attorneys.

<img src=”http://data6.blog.de/media/892/5317892_704b3a97c0_m.jpeg” height=”352″ width=”500″ alt=”In Re Girardi ” />

<img src=”http://data6.blog.de/media/857/5479857_75bd167d2c_m.jpeg” height=”64″ width=”500″ alt=”Skadden Arps Thomas Nolan” />

On July 14 2010, in an attempt to conceal their attorney-client relationship, Skadden Arps and Thomas Nolan filed a motion with the Ninth Circuit asking for their names to be redacted from the published opinion.

According to sources, including TLR’s legal correspondent — known as State Bar Insider (“SBI”) — the arrangement described above is disfavored and unethical; moreover, for such a reltionship to be authorized, Thomas Girardi was required to notify each member of the class he represents about his status as a client of Skadden Arps, and seek a waiver and obtain approval from his clients.

According to SBI, “on its face and based of my reading of “Freivogel on Conflicts,” it appears that Tom Girardi violated his duty of loyalty and zealousness as well as the duty of candor to his clients — the class that he allegedly represents.”

Moreover, according to sources, Skadden Arps has also violated multiple ethical rules and statutes by agreeing to undertake the representation of Girardi & Keese and Thomas Girardi.

A separate source stated: “Assume for the sake of argument that Skadden Arps feels a motion for sanction is warranted against Mr. Girardi in Fogel v. Farmers.  Taking such action would require Skadden to be directly adverse to its client (Thomas Girardi) in the matter of In Re Girardi.”

Moreover, according to SBI, he never heard of a practice by which counsel is asking a court to redact her or his name from a published opinion. “They obviously were attempting to conceal the relationship, and now I am fairly certain as to why it was done,” SBI concluded.

Knowledgeable sources maintain that the ethics complaint seeks the removal of Thomas Girardi’s name from the roll of members of the State Bar of California, and asks that multiple years of actual suspension be imposed on Graham LippSmith, Raoul Kennedy, Thomas Nolan, and Richard Zurmoski.

Ethics Complaint filed with California State Bar against Skadden Arps’ Thomas Nolan/Raoul Kennedy and Girardi Keese’s Thomas Girardi/Graham LippSmith for Alleged Misconduct in Fogel v. Farmers Group Inc.

TLR has learned an ethics complaint alleging multiple acts of misconduct has been filed with the State Bar of California against attorneys from the firms of Skadden, Arps, Slate, Meagher &amp; Flom LLP and Girardi &amp; Keese.

Knowledgeable sources, speaking on condition of anonymity, maintain the complaint alleges that ethical breaches took place as a result of Skadden Arps’ representation of Girardi &amp; Keese in the matter of In Re Girardi because, at the same time, Girardi &amp; Keese and Skadden Arps were on opposing sides in the case of Fogel v. Farmers Group, Inc.

According to the sources, the parties named in the complaint are Raoul Kennedy, Thomas Nolan, and Richard Zurmoski of Skadden Arps as well as Graham LippSmith and Thomas Girardi of Girardi &amp; Keese.

The complaint alleges that in August 2003, Walter Lack (of Engstrom, Lipscomb &amp; Lack) and Thomas Girardi and Graham LippSmith (of Girardi &amp; Keese) filed a class action suit on behalf of plaintiffs Benjamin Fogel against Farmers Group, Inc. in Los Angeles County Superior Court.  The suit — which is still pending and is anticipated to settle in September 2011 — was defended by attorneys from Skadden Arps (Raoul Kennedy and Richard Zurmoski).  
 
Despite their respective roles as plaintiffs’ counsel and defendants’ counsel in Fogel v. Farmers, Girardi &amp; Keese and Skadden Arps entered into an agreement by which Skadden Arps and partner Thomas Nolan would represent Girardi &amp; Keese and Thomas Girardi before the Ninth Circuit in the matter of In re Girardi following the Ninth Circuit’s issuance of an order to show cause why Girardi &amp; Keese, Engstrom Lipscomb &amp; Lack, Thomas Girardi, and Walter Lack should not be suspended, disbarred, or otherwise sanctioned as a result of the massive fraud which took place in litigation pursued by them against Dole Food Company. 

On July 13, 2010, the Ninth Circuit issued an order suspending Walter Lack for a period of six months and reprimanding Girardi; the order also imposed almost $500,000 in monetary sanctions against the two attorneys.

In Re Girardi

Skadden Arps Thomas Nolan

On July 14 2010, in an attempt to conceal their attorney-client relationship, Skadden Arps and Thomas Nolan filed a motion with the Ninth Circuit asking for their names to be redacted from the published opinion.

According to sources, including TLR’s legal correspondent — known as State Bar Insider (“SBI”) — the arrangement described above is disfavored and unethical; moreover, for such a reltionship to be authorized, Thomas Girardi was required to notify each member of the class he represents about his status as a client of Skadden Arps, and seek a waiver and obtain approval from his clients.

According to SBI, “on its face and based of my reading of “Freivogel on Conflicts,” it appears that Tom Girardi violated his duty of loyalty and zealousness as well as the duty of candor to his clients — the class that he allegedly represents.” 

Moreover, according to sources, Skadden Arps has also violated multiple ethical rules and statutes by agreeing to undertake the representation of Girardi &amp; Keese and Thomas Girardi.

A separate source stated: “Assume for the sake of argument that Skadden Arps feels a motion for sanction is warranted against Mr. Girardi in Fogel v. Farmers.  Taking such action would require Skadden to be directly adverse to its client (Thomas Girardi) in the matter of In Re Girardi.”

Moreover, according to SBI, he never heard of a practice by which counsel is asking a court to redact her or his name from a published opinion. “They obviously were attempting to conceal the relationship, and now I am fairly certain as to why it was done,” SBI concluded.

Knowledgeable sources maintain that the ethics complaint seeks the removal of Thomas Girardi’s name from the roll of members of the State Bar of California, and asks that multiple years of actual suspension be imposed on Graham LippSmith, Raoul Kennedy, Thomas Nolan, and Richard Zurmoski.

Categories

RSS .

  • Alliance Backs Bill for Court Reporters in Key Cases 2015/04/17
    Alliance Backs Bill for Court Reporters in Key Cases Dear California Media, Most of us are trial court judges. We have a deep appreciation for the work that court reporters perform. We know that transcripts protect rights. Transcripts clarify complex and subtle rulings. Transcripts preserve testimony; without them, valid grounds for appeal are lost. Transcri […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • The Alliance Responds to the Chief Justice’s State of the Judiciary Address 2015/03/26
    On Monday, the Chief Justice gave her fourth State of the Judiciary address. Her remarks were brief, her tone subdued. In marked contrast with last year’s speech, she did not demand large sums from the Legislature, nor did she decry at length the crisis in our courts. Instead, she spoke about the Magna Carta and […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • If the insiders repeat it enough we will actually believe it? 2015/03/18
    You probably noticed that the insiders on the judicial council, save a few blowhards like judge David Rosenberg who basically framed the latest audit report as a pack of lies were unusually quiet leading up to the legislative hearing. It was only after the hearing that we see other press reports that suggest that the […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • Key Legislator to AOC: “What the hell did you do with that money?” 2015/03/12
    Yesterday, the Joint Legislative Audit Committee and Assembly Budget Subcommittee #5 on Public Safety held hearings on the recent audit of the Judicial Council and the AOC.  State Auditor Elaine Howle did not pull any punches.  She painted an ugly picture of an agency that has lost its way, one that has strayed from its […]
    Judicial Council Watcher
  • Will they walk the talk? 2015/03/12
    Yesterday you heard judge Marsha Slough and Martin Hoshino sit in front of an assembly subcommittee and represent that they’re taking seriously the auditors findings and executing on a strategy to address them. But the two judges McCabe and Wachob were brought aboard the judicial council three years ago with great fanfare and they were […]
    Judicial Council Watcher

RSS Drudge Report Feed

  • Waiting list for LEGAL immigrants surges to 4.4 million... 2015/04/19
    Waiting list for LEGAL immigrants surges to 4.4 million...(Top headline, 1st story, link)
  • ISIS TAKE MORE TO SEA 2015/04/19
    ISIS TAKE MORE TO SEA(Main headline, 1st story, link)
  • Up to 700 feared dead after migrant boat sinks off Libya... 2015/04/19
    Up to 700 feared dead after migrant boat sinks off Libya...(First column, 1st story, link)Related stories:Sea of sorrows; Many drown trying to reach Italy...Pope urges world action...
  • Sea of sorrows; Many drown trying to reach Italy... 2015/04/19
    Sea of sorrows; Many drown trying to reach Italy...(First column, 2nd story, link)Related stories:Up to 700 feared dead after migrant boat sinks off Libya...Pope urges world action...
  • Pope urges world action... 2015/04/19
    Pope urges world action...(First column, 3rd story, link)Related stories:Up to 700 feared dead after migrant boat sinks off Libya...Sea of sorrows; Many drown trying to reach Italy...
  • SHOWDOWN: Iran sending armada of ships towards Yemen... 2015/04/19
    SHOWDOWN: Iran sending armada of ships towards Yemen...(First column, 4th story, link)Related stories:Rouhani warns Saudis...
  • Rouhani warns Saudis... 2015/04/19
    Rouhani warns Saudis...(First column, 5th story, link)Related stories:SHOWDOWN: Iran sending armada of ships towards Yemen...
  • UPDATE: REPUBLICAN CATTLE CALL IN NH... 2015/04/19
    UPDATE: REPUBLICAN CATTLE CALL IN NH...(First column, 6th story, link)Related stories:Clash of Contenders...MAG: Walker Shines...Rand Paul receives standing ovation as he delivers libertarian message...PAPER: RUBIO RISING...FIORINA: Govt 'destroying more businesses' than it's creating...
  • Clash of Contenders... 2015/04/19
    Clash of Contenders...(First column, 7th story, link)Related stories:UPDATE: REPUBLICAN CATTLE CALL IN NH...MAG: Walker Shines...Rand Paul receives standing ovation as he delivers libertarian message...PAPER: RUBIO RISING...FIORINA: Govt 'destroying more businesses' than it's creating...
  • MAG: Walker Shines... 2015/04/19
    MAG: Walker Shines...(First column, 8th story, link)Related stories:UPDATE: REPUBLICAN CATTLE CALL IN NH...Clash of Contenders...Rand Paul receives standing ovation as he delivers libertarian message...PAPER: RUBIO RISING...FIORINA: Govt 'destroying more businesses' than it's creating...
  • Rand Paul receives standing ovation as he delivers libertarian message... 2015/04/19
    Rand Paul receives standing ovation as he delivers libertarian message...(First column, 9th story, link)Related stories:UPDATE: REPUBLICAN CATTLE CALL IN NH...Clash of Contenders...MAG: Walker Shines...PAPER: RUBIO RISING...FIORINA: Govt 'destroying more businesses' than it's creating...
  • PAPER: RUBIO RISING... 2015/04/19
    PAPER: RUBIO RISING...(First column, 10th story, link)Related stories:UPDATE: REPUBLICAN CATTLE CALL IN NH...Clash of Contenders...MAG: Walker Shines...Rand Paul receives standing ovation as he delivers libertarian message...FIORINA: Govt 'destroying more businesses' than it's creating...
  • FIORINA: Govt 'destroying more businesses' than it's creating... 2015/04/19
    FIORINA: Govt 'destroying more businesses' than it's creating...(First column, 11th story, link)Related stories:UPDATE: REPUBLICAN CATTLE CALL IN NH...Clash of Contenders...MAG: Walker Shines...Rand Paul receives standing ovation as he delivers libertarian message...PAPER: RUBIO RISING...
  • World finance leaders see threats ahead for economy... 2015/04/19
    World finance leaders see threats ahead for economy...(First column, 12th story, link)Related stories:PAPER: How sleepy Finland could tear euro apart...
  • PAPER: How sleepy Finland could tear euro apart... 2015/04/19
    PAPER: How sleepy Finland could tear euro apart...(First column, 13th story, link)Related stories:World finance leaders see threats ahead for economy...
  • Email: Affleck asked PBS to not reveal slave-owning ancestor... 2015/04/19
    Email: Affleck asked PBS to not reveal slave-owning ancestor...(First column, 14th story, link)
  • DOWD: Chipotle Granny... 2015/04/19
    DOWD: Chipotle Granny...(Second column, 1st story, link)Related stories:PSYCHOANALYSIS: Why Hillary Can't Be in the Moment...Satire not scandal could derail...PAPER: Thanks to TV's strong women, voters are ready for a female president...STUDY: Hillary earned more than America's top 10 CEOs...DNC planning primary debates...O'MALLEY: ' […]
  • PSYCHOANALYSIS: Why Hillary Can't Be in the Moment... 2015/04/19
    PSYCHOANALYSIS: Why Hillary Can't Be in the Moment...(Second column, 2nd story, link)Related stories:DOWD: Chipotle Granny...Satire not scandal could derail...PAPER: Thanks to TV's strong women, voters are ready for a female president...STUDY: Hillary earned more than America's top 10 CEOs...DNC planning primary debates...O'MALLEY: ' […]
  • Satire not scandal could derail... 2015/04/19
    Satire not scandal could derail...(Second column, 3rd story, link)Related stories:DOWD: Chipotle Granny...PSYCHOANALYSIS: Why Hillary Can't Be in the Moment...PAPER: Thanks to TV's strong women, voters are ready for a female president...STUDY: Hillary earned more than America's top 10 CEOs...DNC planning primary debates...O'MALLEY: ' […]
  • PAPER: Thanks to TV's strong women, voters are ready for a female president... 2015/04/19
    PAPER: Thanks to TV's strong women, voters are ready for a female president...(Second column, 4th story, link)Related stories:DOWD: Chipotle Granny...PSYCHOANALYSIS: Why Hillary Can't Be in the Moment...Satire not scandal could derail...STUDY: Hillary earned more than America's top 10 CEOs...DNC planning primary debates...O'MALLEY: ' […]
.